“All these moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain.”
- Roy Batty, Blade Runner
One late evening, while discussing the finite nature of anime series over coffee and muffins (which is a classy way of saying that we were bumming around a donut shop), a friend of mine said: “Nobody’s going to remember K-ON! in a few years.” It was just an off-hand remark in a very long conversation, but as time goes on and the rest of what we said fades away, that particular moment sticks in my memory. Phenomenal sales aside, I believe it’s pretty much true. K-ON! will be forgotten.

I was talking with someone else on the train ride to work, not about anime but about philosophy. According to him, the difference between western and eastern philosophy is that the former attempts to explain the nature of existence, while the latter is concerned with one’s capacity to intuitively “feel” existence.
For example, consider the Japanese artistic concept of mono no aware. We can try to explain it as the warm bittersweetness of life, a nostalgic sadness for the way everything eventually ends… But such phrases have zero emotional impact. The best way to understand mono no aware is to experience it in life, and from there to see it reflected through art.
There are some very good books that I could recommend, which will have a greater effect if you’ve been through college, the first years of your twenties, or what-have-you. Or you could save yourself some time and just watch K-ON!

I recall some people being unhappy that the series ended the way it did, on a normal winter day with everyone doing their own thing. On the contrary, I thought it was brilliant. The previous twelve episodes tell us explicitly again and again that the light music club is special—as long as they’re playing together, everything works out. But episode thirteen takes off the rosy glasses and reminds us that they won’t be together forever, even if they eventually meet up at the end of the day. Next year’s school festival is probably the last the world will see of “After School Tea Time.” In all likelihood, the girls will graduate and go their separate ways, perhaps once in a while looking back fondly on their days in high school.
The magic is that they never have to SAY so. There’s no sad graduation episode, or even any acknowledgement like we saw in the final episode of Lucky Star. It is simply understood.

I hear there’s an extra episode coming out with the DVDs. But unless Kyoto Animation surprises us, that’s probably the last we’ll see of K-ON! For the people who really liked the show, of course it’s a little bit sad. But I think that’s okay. We’ve enjoyed it, and now it’s over. That’s just life. It’s the transience of things.
August 27, 2009 at 10:01 am
This post makes me want to rewatch the show :3 Never thought about the ending like that ~ (not that I disliked how it ended; I thought it was just fine)
August 27, 2009 at 1:14 pm
Oh, by all means, please do. It makes me feel like I’ve done my job in the world for today.
August 27, 2009 at 10:32 am
I said somewhere that the last episode is a nice way to send off the audience, so I fully agree with you here.
I tried to say something more meaningful, but I can’t. So, great post, and glad to see someone appreciate that last episode the same way I did.
August 27, 2009 at 1:18 pm
It seemed like positive responses to the ending weren’t quite as numerous as ambivalent ones, so I may have actually read yours at some point. Apologies that I can’t seem to remember. And thanks for reading.
August 27, 2009 at 12:14 pm
If it is forgotten, it will be forgottenin such a way that real fans keep it in their favorites list, mention it once in a while, and new fans 10 years from now will only find out about it if they have friends or blogs they read who have been watching anime for a lot longer than they have. Or when people are studying Kyoto Animation a few years down. But yes, it will be largely forgotten.
Sad, but it happens to all kinds of anime.
August 27, 2009 at 1:09 pm
Had “Someday In The Rain” been the actual last broadcast episode of Suzumiya Haruhi, I imagine it might have achieved the same effect. But Kyoto Animation seems to have gone in an entirely different direction with that show, especially now. In retrospect, I’m glad it was saved for K-ON!
August 27, 2009 at 12:40 pm
Well done. This perspective makes me appreciate the show more. Thank you. This is why I love anime blogs. For some of us, it’s our own personal Budokan.
—
Well, as long as KyoAni exists and is relevant there’s a chance for it to be remembered if no longer relevant. A precedent is indeed GAINAX whose less popular works somehow benefit from association with its Evangelions and Gurren Laganns (e.g. Kare Kano, Oruchuban Ebichu, the Buster shows); this and GAINAX markets their brands well I think, w/c KyoAni will do well to emulate and exceed.
August 27, 2009 at 1:12 pm
You’re very welcome. For what it’s worth, I think I really like being in the ani-blogosphere.
Seeing K-ON! characters make a cameo in some future KyoAni production would make me profoundly pleased.
August 27, 2009 at 2:46 pm
Although that’s the case, it still won’t stop me from listing them as one of my top anime’s of all time.
August 27, 2009 at 3:46 pm
Whenever I think of “mono no aware,” I always think of the Japaneses’ love for their cherry blossoms; things that are so beautiful and inspiring, yet fleeting.
As for K-ON!, I don’t think it will be completely forgotten, since it was such a big hit; fans just won’t care or think about it much anymore. Since so much anime is produced all the time, so many just come and go, but I think K-ON! might have a little more staying power than the run-of-the-mill series. In a few years perhaps, but in 30+ years, will people still be talking about Haruhi and Lucky Star? Series like Evangelion are rare exceptions so we’ll just have to wait and see if there will be another long lasting anime legend.
August 28, 2009 at 5:28 am
You, dear sir, need to ease up on slice-of-life animu. Gakuen Utopia Tsumugi Straight will live on in our hearts forever.
August 29, 2009 at 6:00 am
I know what you mean about open ended anime that just give the viewer some leeway to better understand and conclude the show in their own minds rather than having it frankly mentioned or written on the walls. Most of the shows I have enjoyed the most have open endings in some form.
Oh and K’on will be forgotten, and I say this as someone that enjoyed the show. It really just didn’t frenzied following of Haruhi or the polarizing nature of Evangelion.
August 30, 2009 at 10:33 am
Damn, I’d almost forgotten about that line in Blade Runner. I’m not sure if I’m alone in thinking that it’s the most interesting aspect of the film, since it’s so groundbreaking in so many areas. Anyway. There’s a wonderful train of thought you have going on here.
I honestly can’t believe K-On! was so fantastically popular. A couple of months ago you couldn’t walk more than a few metres into a comic or video shop in Akiba without a stand of CDs or other merch…and yet, I recall fans in the West being really divided over it.
What I like about the show is indeed the transience of it – I don’t consider it being an enduring classic that’s remembered a decade or more down the line. But yeah, I think it was never intended to be anything other than disposable fun by the writers anyway. Some series are meant to be enjoyed by later generations of viewers but I don’t think this is one of them. And there’s nothing wrong with that either.
I’ve yet to see the final episodes (now I’ve read this post I REALLY want to see them now), but an ending like the one you describe here sounds really appropriate to me: it’s a depiction of a short period of the characters’ lives, after all.
September 1, 2009 at 4:03 pm
I have a confession to make: I haven’t finished watching K-ON! that is FAIL, considering that I once rallied forth to defend K-ON!. OTL.
And you, dear sir, have served as the great reminder that there is much to gained by finishing
the raceitA fun little Sunday drive it will be ^^
September 1, 2009 at 4:09 pm
“…much to be gained”, albeit being transient. Though I’d like to think it’ll leave a ‘lingering feeling’ even after it ends, definitely something you could look back to and make you go Fuwa Fuwa [Time]~
September 3, 2009 at 6:01 pm
Great post. I never looked at the last episode in this way, but I felt that it was more pleasing than the rest. I think it was the part of the series that was the most “slice-of-life” oriented.
January 2, 2010 at 9:25 am
[...] last time I wrote about K-ON!, Kyoto Animation’s high school rock darling, I was confident that this was anime’s heavy metal love ballad to “mono no aware”: It would be forgotten, or perhaps wistfully remembered here and there. But a lot of things have [...]