I’m back from a morning screening of The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya. I promised Yumeka that I’d give a full report tout-suite, so here we go, organized haphazardly with as few introductory frills as possible. As for spoilers, please proceed at your own risk.
Looks like “The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya” is the official English title, since that’s what we got on the screen in white letters at the very start. The movie begins from Kyon’s eye view, as he reluctantly gets out of bed in the morning. This is a motif that will repeat itself several times more before the two and a half hours are up. From there, we get an exacting adaptation of the novel. With the exception of a line or two, the script is utterly faithful to the original. This was a big bonus for me, since my Japanese is quite poor. I was able to follow along, and I was entertained enough to ignore the gaps in understanding.
The identity of who caused the incident is both mysterious and totally not. We don’t get to hear Tanabata-Era Nagato say the name, but her lips are animated enough that we can actually lip-read two of the three syllables. I suspect this is more a matter of following the book’s style than really expecting anyone to be surprised. By the way, the animation is gorgeous, as expected of KyoAni. The numerous instances where Kyon finds himself at a FamilyMart hint at where some of the money came from.
There is an updated version of the original Haruhi opening. The music sounds slightly different, and Aya Hirano sounds a little harder or deeper than she originally was, but it’s pretty much the same song. The animation is a rainbow pattern of Haruhi silhouettes doing various things in unison, while in a separate window the club members are shown entering one by one and gathering around the heater. At the end of the “OP,” there’s only one silhouette left, and she slowly disappears into a trapdoor. Spooky.
Speaking of music, up until the disappearance happens, we get regular music from the TV show. But immediately afterwards and for the rest of the movie, it’s mostly orchestral arrangements. A lot of it sounds rousing and adventurous, especially when Kyon starts putting the pieces together. I liked it as a tone-setter.
Seeing everything in motion before my eyes, I now definitely see the story’s homage to Back to the Future Part II. Kyon hiding from himself and Mikuru, for one, but in the café scene where Alt-Koizumi describes the possibilities of what’s happened, he draws a diagram on a napkin suspiciously similar to Doc Brown’s explanation of the alternate 1985. That was kind of neat.
Asakura’s last scene was fabulous. If there was one moment when I was truly on the edge of my seat, that was it.
Yuki… Wow, where to start? Alt-Yuki’s voice is higher, more fragile and uncertain sounding. It’s actually kind of freaky, seeing this person who is almost Nagato Yuki in every way including the way she sounds, but ever so slightly off. Props to Chihara Minori for her voice work.
The moe for Alt-Yuki is incredibly strong. KyoAni added some details: When she holds Kyon’s sleeve when he’s about to leave her apartment, she not only blushes, but the tops of her ears turn red also. When Kyon decides to activate the emergency program and returns the Literature Club application to Yuki, the book says that Kyon can’t see her expression. In the movie, she has a look on her face like she’s about to burst into tears, but then she just barely holds it in. Ah, that scene really hurt… But it was very well done, a great embellishment.
Kyon’s realization at the climax, that he’s been having fun and that he wants everything back, is handled with Evangelion-esque abstractions and conversations with avatars. I wasn’t expecting that. It was brief and quite deftly handled, though; better to see Kyon actually argue with himself than to simply hear his monologue at such an important time.
Shippers are in for a delight. I won’t say how, but Kyon demonstrates real attraction to and affection for Haruhi in one of the last scenes. Yuki also gets a great rooftop scene with Kyon, too, where he may (or may not) have called her by her first name for the first time. Again, these are KyoAni embellishments that made the whole thing so much better.
The film ends not as I thought it would (perhaps with some version of Hare Hare Yukai): After Kyon says his last line from the book, it’s just plain black and white scrolling credits, set to a song sung by Chihara Minori with no accompaniment. I couldn’t get the entirety of it, but it sounded like Alt-Yuki, or real Yuki in her heart of hearts, telling us not to forget… something. It was haunting.
Lastly, I was happy to see at the very end of the credits, in English:
Special Thanks
All fans
That was nice. And when you watch, remember that there’s something afterwards!
Okay, I think that ought to do it. This is literally twice the length of a usual blog entry. I’ll write about my actual experience next time, if there’s interest.
Oh, I also got a booklet with what looks like exclusive art from Noizi Itoh.
Not sure, though.
God… This was worth the long journey (I’ll talk about that later if there’s interest), but right now I am so tired.




February 6, 2010 at 11:08 am
Well done, catching this on the big screen! I’ll have to content myself with a DVD (or better yet, a Blu-ray) release, which I hope won’t be too long in coming.
“From there, we get an exacting adaptation of the novel. With the exception of a line or two, the script is utterly faithful to the original. This was a big bonus for me, since my Japanese is quite poor. I was able to follow along, and I was entertained enough to ignore the gaps in understanding.”
Very glad to hear that, in view of the fact that my Japanese isn’t too far advanced either. Having read the original work, I feel more comfortable now with ordering the Japanese video release as soon as it’s confirmed (rather than waiting for someone to bid on the overseas licence).
February 6, 2010 at 11:17 am
Hey, a comment right before bed. That’s the best kind.
That’s a great point, actually. Not that I necessarily want to undercut the possibility of a full English-language release, but if you’ve read the novel and know the story, you can in fact order the Japanese DVD when the time comes and enjoy it just fine. I’m sure Kyoto Animation wouldn’t complain.
Thanks for reading.
February 6, 2010 at 2:53 pm
I’m excited to see this now, though I wouldn’t mind the wait. Thanks for taking note of the embellishments.
February 8, 2010 at 8:15 am
I’m glad. Frankly, I was kind of afraid that after posting this review I’d be met with a flood of hate, just because that’s what I hear people do sometimes. But everyone just seems real excited and happy to know the details. It’s great.
For what it’s worth, I think it will be worth waiting for.
Thanks for reading.
February 6, 2010 at 3:39 pm
Giggling like a fangirl here~
February 8, 2010 at 8:17 am
Fabulous. I’m glad to know it.
The DVD’s worth pouncing on the moment it comes out. Which I have no doubt you’ll do.
February 6, 2010 at 4:47 pm
Thanks for the review ^_^ A few spur-of-the-moment reviews are popping up on the AnimeSuki forums and elsewhere, but I think yours is the first full English one.
I was expecting some criticism from you (since I know you’re not a hardcore fan of the series) but I’m glad you had a lot of positive things to say about it. Actually, so far I’ve heard nothing but positive reviews, but that’s probably because only the major fans went to see it the first day.
Can’t wait to see it for myself.
And I’ll be linking back to your post now =)
February 8, 2010 at 8:19 am
Kyoto Animation has the right touch, I think. What in text seems insufferable turns out to be actually kind of likeable. They did a good job.
And I know you’re linking back, even if you didn’t tell me. About a quarter of the incoming visits are coming from your entry.
Thanks for the publicity.
February 6, 2010 at 4:49 pm
holy shit. its out? I’m so envious!!!
February 8, 2010 at 8:23 am
I wish I could soothe your envy by psychically implanting my memories of the event. But it would include a lot of cold and hunger and neck pain from horrible seats. So for what it’s worth, I paid my dues.
Thanks for reading.
February 6, 2010 at 4:51 pm
[...] My friend 2DT was one of the lucky ones who got to see the movie on opening day. His review here. I believe it’s the first full English [...]
February 6, 2010 at 4:52 pm
Oh my godohmygodohmygod.
I have NEVER been so excited about anything ever.
Not even a child on Christmas Eve compares to how I am feeling right now!
February 8, 2010 at 8:24 am
Ever? That must be some incredible excitement… Well, I’m glad, though! I hope this whets your appetite for the film. Thanks for stopping by.
February 6, 2010 at 5:37 pm
Man, I really cannot wait to see this. I’m not sure if I’m more excited to see Alt-Yuki or Kyon’s big GAR EFF YOU moment at the end. Kyon is awesome in this story because he takes so much action instead of remaining passive.
February 8, 2010 at 8:27 am
As someone who isn’t a Kyon fan normally, I have to admit he won me over by the end. In fact, in a way, I feel like this movie completes the series, since Kyon, the narrator and the real center of everything, finally tackles his issues head-on.
You’re a familiar face on other peoples’ blogs, but I believe this is the first time you’ve commented on mine…. Welcome!
February 6, 2010 at 5:45 pm
Uhh how spoilerific is this review…?
February 6, 2010 at 11:39 pm
If you’ve read the book, not very much at all.
If you haven’t… there are a couple of moments I mention that shouldn’t be TOO surprising, like the decisions that Kyon makes. Still, tread carefully, I suppose.
February 9, 2010 at 6:10 am
I’ll hold off for now. I wanna be completely surprised.
February 6, 2010 at 8:44 pm
I didn’t know it was out yet either O_o. And I still haven’t watched season 2.
February 8, 2010 at 8:29 am
Want to know something? I haven’t, either. At least not past Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody and the first two episodes of Endless Eight. Considering the controversy over “The Sigh,” I guess I’d better get on it.
Thanks for reading.
February 6, 2010 at 10:57 pm
I don’t like The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. I watched most of the first season and was unimpressed. But, dammit, the pictures of Asakura and Yuki together make me want to watch it just so I can then go look at yuri fanart of the two… damn you! (For the record, I only watched as much as the first season as I did for similar reasons, but with Kyon and Itsuki yaoi as my ultimate goal… I am afraid of drawing any conclusions of what this could mean about me, as I feel they could only be unsettling in nature….)
February 8, 2010 at 8:34 am
Really? But Itsuki’s so… unbearably long-winded. The pillow talk afterwards would put them to sleep.
Asakura is very sweet to Alt-Yuki. I liked that a lot… But, uh, some things happen that might sour any potential yuri pairing for you.
Still, you should see the movie when you get the chance. It’s just one evening’s entertainment, and very worthwhile in my opinion.
February 7, 2010 at 2:00 am
A bona fide review!
Well, synopsis as well, but you noticing the Back to the Future reference was awesome. It’s a homage in splendid taste. Faithfulness is a big winner when it comes to movie adaptations, too. Maybe it’s about time I forgave Kyo-ani for what happened a while back and actually watch through the rest of Haruhi in anticipation of this.
February 8, 2010 at 8:38 am
By “what happened,” you mean Endless Eight? That was pretty shameless, I agree. But it’s long over now; now it’s just another set of very expensive DVDs, or an archive of eight very similar files on peoples’ hard drives. Know what I mean?
I’ll be restarting Haruhi S2 myself, so let’s try slogging through it together.
February 7, 2010 at 7:43 am
I like the first season but the second season ruined Haruhi for me. I’ve read the Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya light novel, haven’t read Sigh yet, but this movie looks like a return to classic Haruhi stylin’.
I didn’t like K-ON! at all, and the imposition of K-ON! onto Haruhi was just wrong. I understand there are people who love watching K-ON! but maybe the manga four-koma coming out will convince me that K-ON! is worth it.
Going through a phase of internal reflection about my anime viewing habits right now, it’s basically the only hobby I have left apart from reading, writing and photography that still has any real feeling left in it for me.
February 8, 2010 at 8:44 am
The movie continues to evolve the style, so I don’t know how happy you’d be. But it’s definitely less like they’re fresh off of K-ON!
Anime, reading, writing and photography are huge hobbies by themselves. I think you can be quite happy with them, for what it’s worth. Don’t introspect TOO much.
February 7, 2010 at 8:13 am
Didn’t care for the novel (I do NOT like normal girl Yuki since she’s pretty much the antithesis of alien Yuki, and alien Yuki is fun.), but hearing that it compares to Back to the Future 2 in some ways gives me hope that I’ll like the movie as much as I like the TV series.
My love for the series pretty much comes from the ways the anime made embelishments and “improvements” on the novel. Good to hear that sort of stuff is in the movie. Was worried that the straight-forward movie format might lead them towards being too literal.
February 8, 2010 at 8:46 am
It’s still quite literal, to the point where (as I said above), if you’ve read the novel, you could very well watch the movie without subtitles and be fine. But I think Kyoto Animation recognizes that they’re still a company producing modern visual culture, so a lot of the changes and enhancements are a treat for the eyes.
When you get the chance to see it, I’d be curious to know what you think. Let me know. Cheers.
February 8, 2010 at 12:26 am
Funny thing is though even the movie says Dissapeearnce the soundtrack cover says Vanishment xD
I guess they just don’t know themselves what to call it! :p
February 8, 2010 at 8:47 am
Oh, does it?
Well, back to the drawing board. But thanks for stopping by!
February 8, 2010 at 8:58 am
Nice, nice, nice review!
Thanks a lot from an italian haruhist!
You gave me the taste of a full view…
…and the hunger for a real view!
February 8, 2010 at 9:20 am
Oh, uh… molto bene?
Well, I’m glad! Thanks for reading.
February 8, 2010 at 5:35 pm
I read the novels this far, not terribly impressed, but after reading your review…
MUST WATCH O_O
February 8, 2010 at 9:29 pm
I too wasn’t blown away by the novel. It was just some decent light reading. But having a visual component really improves the experience.
I hope you can wait.
I’m sure it won’t be too long.
February 9, 2010 at 7:34 am
Is this something I should watch after I see the second season?
February 9, 2010 at 8:13 am
The only thing you MUST watch from the second season to appreciate this movie is Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody, the first two episodes. And maybe get the gist of Endless Eight, knowing that Yuki was conscious of the entire thing. After that, you’ll be pretty much where I was going in.
February 10, 2010 at 7:41 am
Been a Haruhi fan for nearly two years. Read all the books. Never thought of dropping the series when EE was airing. There was a reason – Yuki. Always clay doll-like, but… her single move and look could say more then a dozen of words. Even now I watch the snowflakes fly around outside and almost tremble with anticipation to see the movie.
Thank you for posting from a russian haruhist fan beyond help!
February 10, 2010 at 5:43 pm
nice post i would like to travel to japan and watch the movie in the “giant screen” but im so so far away im gonna wait until the dvd version release u.u. maybe in some months ..well continue whit your blog i will be waiting for more post XD
best wishes and good luck
February 12, 2010 at 10:19 am
Thank you for the review.
Admittedly, I was getting a little tired of the “plastic youth” scenario that Tanigawa had created, so the book was refreshing in its execution. Judging from this review, this film may be a little more than just “refreshing.”
I will be awaiting the Western release with anticipation.
February 13, 2010 at 6:48 pm
[...] a bit of a disappointment for me. Since impression posts I've read about it seemed to range from contented to ecstatic, I might as well try and explain why. This shouldn't spoil anything if you're familiar [...]
April 20, 2010 at 8:11 am
I saw the film via camrip just last night. I know, camrips = forty lashes with a wet noodle, but anyways.
I’m a huge Haruhi Suzumiya nut, and I am entirely with you on the whole thing; this film was fantastic, and the best film I’ve ever seen. I’ve heard people say that the film drags on, but I had no such problem. Whoever says it does is empty-headed and shallow: those “dragged out” scenes actually helped things in the film sink in better and allowed for the film to be more memorable on a first-time viewing. (especially at the climax with Kyon’s inner turmoil of “Normal vs. Paranormal”, and Asakura’s big scene (KyoAni made that part go from “creepy” to “straight-up nightmare-worthy”)) The animation and cinematography was a tour de force; rather than have it be like the TV series with a few added frames and an extra coat of gloss, it actually looked and (most importantly) felt like a motion picture!! And I also give props to Minori Chihara: her portrayal of Alt-Yuki was spot-on.
Oh, and my favorite line from the movie went something like this:
Kyon: “Taniguchi, tell Okabe that I’m leaving early today and tell him I’m dying of pneumonia, typhoid and dysentery all at the same time.” I had to pause the movie, I was laughing so hard!!
I totally can’t wait for the US DVD. I. Am. BUYING THIS!! Then I’ll show everyone at my high-school anime club. :3
April 20, 2010 at 9:49 am
Glad you enjoyed it. What you could also do is force everyone in your anime club to read the novel, then buy the Japanese DVD and show it raw. That would be an interesting exercise.
May 5, 2010 at 6:17 pm
XD I suppose so. But, no, I’m gonna show them the subbed version instead. Besides, how the hell am I gonna get all those Disappearance books?! (Book is being released in English November 2, 2010. Guess what’s going on my Christmas list this year?
)
May 4, 2010 at 9:12 pm
Asakura/Nagato!
Even with the end part, the cheek-stroking got me shipping it even harder, if possible.
Not to mention Asakura is such a powerful character! I often wonder why she’s not more well-liked. ):
May 5, 2010 at 6:29 am
Well, if I had to guess, being a psychotic killer might have something to do with it.
But I’m glad you found shipping potential. The way their personalities clash is pretty fun.
May 5, 2010 at 4:46 pm
That makes me intruiging, though! Haha. XD
Oh, believe me, I’m glad too. (I also found a little Asahina/Nagato, strangely enough, augh get away my slash-loving persona)
May 12, 2010 at 8:46 am
Haruhi Suzumiya is in a TV ad for lotte gum
http://www.japansugoi.com/wordpress/lotte-acuo-gum-tvcm-features-haruhi-suzumiya/
July 5, 2010 at 3:01 pm
Watched the movie – it was nizzle.
This might spoil some of the plot. Just so you know!
I feel bad for Nagato
having her emotions taken away like that when she just got them back. It’s hard for Kyon though too staying in that “dimension” after he has built up such good relationships with haruhi and the others in the other dimension. Haruhi also didn’t seem to have the same happy expression in the “normal dimension” as in the one where she has sUperpOwers. If i remember correctly Kyon also says that we might not realize it but a world with organic robots, espers, time-travelers and a supergirl is far more fun! hmm, if i were in his place maybe i would be a little concerned about haruhi being able to turn the world upside down, which has also nearly happened before. I might consider living in a world where she doesn’t have any superpowerS. In his place i would have to be the one stopping the world from going under – exciting? ye sure, but enormously creepy… i don’t really think i could live with that xb. Kyon is a tough guy! Or maybe just too careless ^^. I would have chosen the “normal dimension” even though i would have lost those special relationships. I really like haruhi though, it’s a sad choice.
What would you do? ^^
July 5, 2010 at 3:07 pm
what do you think happened to the blue-haired killer (asakura.. i think) after he was stapped?
July 5, 2010 at 3:08 pm
stabbed… i know there might be other mistakes ^^
December 26, 2010 at 1:38 pm
Is “john smith” a homage to doctor who?
Btw
who rescues kyon at the end? I havent read the novel, does kyon and the rest travel back in time again at the end of the novel or is it part of aother novel?
December 26, 2010 at 2:05 pm
Hmm… You know, it could be! I know that the current Doctor Who series is airing dubbed in Japan, so it’s possible that there is a fanbase for it. Nice catch!
It’s implied at the end of the movie that Kyon rescues Kyon, and he recognizes that he’s going to have to go back in time eventually to rescue himself.
December 26, 2010 at 7:04 pm
But. The rescue is still not part of any of the novels, right?
December 26, 2010 at 8:35 pm
Hmm. It isn’t? Not being a reader of the novels myself (except Disappearance, which I made an exception for), I couldn’t tell you. Sorry!
January 4, 2011 at 3:54 pm
yesh, he goes back on that time…
it was included on the later novels how he saved himself during that night…
also the part on what happened to Asakura when facing Yuki… and (spoilers!) the YukixYuki encounter >.<
Buy the Novels (or lurk the internetz) if you want to know what happened…
btw… I think Kyon would make that "john smith" name very useful on the 10th novel, knowing what had happened during the 9th ;D
January 5, 2011 at 4:26 am
awesome!, i think i will read them
February 24, 2011 at 12:47 pm
OMG! Barney does the Hare Hare Yukai too LOL
http://www.japansugoi.com/wordpress/even-barney-knows-hare-hare-yukai/